Clark Goble, whose web-blog I thoroughly enjoy and read as often as I can because he is just so dadgum interesting, has finally caught my attention on something that I can disagree gently with him enough, to actually disagree in print. His discussion of the worse science books he has ever read is wonderful! It's here:
http://www.libertypages.com/clark/10887.html
Where I disagree with my well read, and truly informed friend is where he says or perhaps just hints, that Gary Zokav's book "The Dancing Wu Li Masters" is on the same calibre of Fritjof Capra's book "The Tao of Physics."
I disagree quite strongly. Zukav's book is a terrific overview (which is what he was doing, not writing as a scientist in the first place). In fact, it was Zukav who got me far more interested in the quantum physics than anyone else I had read. Zukav's explanations are clear, they are logical, and they are tantalizing! That is far and away more than I can say of many scientific writings about the quantum.
I think the scientists themselves are beginning to realize that all the gobble-de gook they write is so far over all our heads, and it doesn't impress us, not in the way they thought it would with all their overly obtuse vocabulary.
It's about stinkin time SOMEONE comes along and says look, lets say it simple, yet be accurate, and yet give the flavor of just what in the sam hell is going on. Zukav did that for me.
And.....AND........ because of the way he described Einstein's ideas, and some of the various quantum interpretations, I got INTERESTED and have never let go since. To lump Zukav with Capra is a travesty of misunderstanding. The two books are no more alike than the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews.
I still admire ya though Clark, more than you will ever know, for the stellar shining light of wonderful knowledge and analysis that you present to the rest of us here in Cyberspace.
P.S. I actually agree with you as well concerning Hawking. And when I bought the tapes of his book and listened to them, they were not near as fascinating and interesting to listen to as Zukav's tapes on his own book. Yet another book that I have, and the tapes of it as well to listen to, I cannot for the life of me read "The Physics of Immortality" either. I just could not get into that book at all in any manner, and I tried reading it, listening to it etc., just no dice.......
Recent Comments